I got a call this week from a client who is remodeling her primary bathroom. She asked if it was okay to remove the tub to make room for a larger walk-in shower. If I had a loofah sponge for every time I’ve been asked this question, I’d have a lot of loofahs. There’s a lot that goes into answering that question. How many other bathtubs are there? Do you want a tub? Do you have children? Do you plan on having children? How long do you plan on living in the home?

These questions are crucial when considering such a significant change in your bathroom. Let’s dive deeper into the pros and cons of replacing your master bathtub with a walk-in shower.

Pros of Replacing the Master Bathtub with a Walk-In Shower

1. Modern Appeal

Walk-in showers are often seen as more contemporary and stylish compared to traditional bathtubs. They can give your bathroom a sleek, modern look that many homeowners and buyers find appealing.

2. Space Efficiency

Walk-in showers typically take up less space than a bathtub, or they can make better use of the existing space, creating a more open and airy feel in your bathroom. This can be especially beneficial in smaller bathrooms.

3. Accessibility

Walk-in showers are much easier to access than bathtubs, making them a great option for elderly homeowners or those with mobility issues. Adding features like grab bars and non-slip flooring can further enhance safety.

4. Ease of Cleaning

Showers generally require less cleaning and maintenance than bathtubs. They don’t have the deep basin that can accumulate grime and are easier to wipe down regularly.

5. Energy and Water Efficiency

Showers can be more water-efficient than baths, particularly if you install a low-flow showerhead. This can lead to savings on your water bill and is better for the environment

Cons of Replacing the Master Bathtub with a Walk-In Shower

1. Potential Impact on Resale Value

If your home doesn’t have another bathtub, removing the master tub can negatively impact resale value. Many families, particularly those with young children, prefer having at least one bathtub in the home.

2. Personal Preference

Consider your preferences and lifestyle. If you enjoy soaking in a tub after a long day, you might regret not having that option. A bathtub can offer a relaxing retreat that a shower may not provide.

3. Future Family Plans

If you currently don’t have children but plan to in the future, keeping at least one bathtub in the home might be practical. Bathtubs are often preferred for bathing young children.

4. Cost Considerations

The cost of converting a bathtub into a walk-in shower can vary significantly depending on the complexity of the work and the materials chosen. Ensure your budget for potential plumbing adjustments, new fixtures, and tiling.

Key Questions to Consider

1. How many other bathtubs are there in your home?

  • If there are other bathtubs, particularly in secondary bathrooms, the impact on resale value might be less significant.

2. Do you plan to sell your home soon?

  • If you plan on selling soon, consider the preferences of potential buyers in your area. Research or consult a real estate agent to understand the market trends.

3. What is your budget for the remodel?

  • Ensure your budget can cover the costs of the conversion without compromising other essential updates or repairs.

4. How long do you plan on living in your home?

  • If you plan to stay long-term, prioritize your comfort and preferences. If a walk-in shower suits your needs better, it may be worth the investment.


Can I replace my bathtub with a walk-in shower?

Deciding whether to replace your master bathtub with a walk-in shower is a significant decision that depends on various factors, including your lifestyle, family needs, and future plans. While a walk-in shower can add modern appeal and improve accessibility, it’s essential to weigh these benefits against the potential impact on resale value and personal preference.

Ultimately, consider what will make you happiest and most comfortable in your home. Consulting with a remodeling expert and a real estate agent can also provide valuable insights tailored to your specific situation. Whatever you decide, ensure it enhances the enjoyment and functionality of your living space.  As always, give us a call.  We’re happy to help you walk through the pros and cons of a walk-in!

    View All Selling Posts